Abstract. I am discussing three strategies of fitting supererogation within
consequentialist frameworks, namely Slote’s (1984) and Scheffler’s (1994). My main claim is that not only the utilitarian or consequentialist framework is modified to accommodate supererogation, but also the concept of supererogation suffers transformations in the process. It is therefore questionable if the theories discussed manage indeed to make room for the commonsensical moral intuitions carried by the concept of supererogation.
Keywords: Ethical Theories, Supererogation, Consequentialism, Optimization, Satisficing.
Dreier, James (2004). Why Ethical Satisficing Makes Sense and
Rational Satisficing Doesn’t. In Satisficing and Maximizing,
edited by Michael Byron, 131-154. Cambridge: Cambridge
Hampton, Jean (1992). “Selflessness and the Loss of Self.” Social
Philosophy and Policy 10: 135-165.
Heyd, David (1982). Supererogation: Its Status in Ethical Theory.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hurka, Thomas (1990). “Two Kinds of Satisficing.” Philosophical
Studies 59: 107-111.
Hurka, Thomas, and Schubert, Esther (2012). “Permissions to Do
Less Than the Best: A Moving Band.” Oxford Studies in
Normative Ethics 2: 1–27.
Jenkins, Carrie S., and Nolan, Daniel (2010). “Maximising, Satisficing
and Context.” Noûs 44: 451-468.
Mellema, Gregory (1991). Beyond the Call of Duty: Supererogation,
Obligation, and Offence. State University of New York Press.
New, Christopher (1974). “Saints, Heroes and Utilitarians.”
Philosophy 49: 179-189.
Portmore, Douglas W. (2003). “Position-Relative Consequentialism,
Agent-Centered Options, and Supererogation.” Ethics
Scheffler, Samuel (1994). The Rejection of Consequentialism: A
Philosophical Investigation of the Considerations Underlying
Rival Moral Conceptions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Slote, Michael (1984). “Morality and Self-Other Asymmetry.”
Journal of Philosophy 81: 179-192.
Vessel, Jean-Paul (2010). “Supererogation for Utilitarianism.”
American Philosophical Quarterly 47: 299-319.
Williams, Bernard A.O. (1981). Moral Luck: Philosophical Papers,
1973-1980. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Zimmerman, Michael J. (1993). “Supererogation and Doing the
Best One Can.” American Philosophical Quarterly 30: 373-380.